Which Rendition of “A Christmas Carol” Should I Watch?

While some movie versions of Charles Dickens’ classic “A Christmas Carol” do not make the list as they are so bad or perverted , such as Bill Murry’s “Scrooged”, others don’t make the list because they are so different from the original, like D. James Kennedy’s 2001, “Scrooge and Marley”.  This latter one is well worth watching, but just very different from the original book.

#7. Our countdown from worst to best starts with Basil Rathbone’s 1954 version. Although Basil Rathbone plays a great Sherlock Holmes and his role as Marley is the best actor in this movie, his hair stiffly sticking out straight out the back of his head like an arrow was just too absurd.   Next, Belle singing a ridiculous and redundant lamenting song concerning what ‘present’ she should buy youthful Ebenezer for Christmas, when only seconds later to directly dump him after her love song concluded, was nauseating.  Followed by the colossal misinterpretation of the Ghost of “Christmas Present” being re-constructed as a “gift” (present=gift), made you wonder if anyone had even read the book.  However, to top it all off, the third spirit didn’t even show up, which seals this as the worst of our seven.  When the movie ended, I was glad they were done.

#6.  If you like musicals the 1970 version of “Scrooge” starring Albert Finney may be for you.  We wrestled with watching the movie, but when Ebenezer slid through Bob Cratchet’s front door on a sled dressed as Santa, we threw in the towel.

#5. Another musical is the 2004 Hallmark version starring Kelsey Grammer, but when one of the spirits, scantily dressed, became a pole-dancer on Ebenezer’s bedpost, that was enough on this one.

#4. Disney’s animated 2009 version seemed to show that they could not decide whether they were doing “A Christmas Carol”, or “Darby O’Gill and the Little People”. They even had the banchee death coach showing up.

#3.  George C. Scott does an excellent job in his 1984 portrayal of Ebenezer Scrooge and is worth watching.  It does deviate from the book a little and might be missing some of the Christian flavor of the movie.  Overall, it is a good rendition.

#2. The 1951 version starring Alastair Sim’s is an excellent rendition and was our family’s favorite for years.  We enjoyed the Bible Verses. There is even a colorized version available making it appealing to the younger generation.  This one is well worth your time.

#1.  The absolute best rendition that we have found is Patrick Stewart’s 1999 portrayal of Ebenezer Scrooge.    This version is very true to the original 1843 Christian allegory written by Charles’s Dickens.  This version is very nearly word for word with the story.  Patrick Stewart was designed for his role since he had performed a one man telling of the story for a decade prior to his role in this movie. It even has the redeemed Ebenezer going to church on Christmas morning (as in the book) with Ebenezer pledging to keep Christmas in his heart every day of the year — which is a good idea for all of us.  Merry Christmas!